For big family celebrations, there’s nothing like a large roast turkey or a succulent joint of meat – but to cook them to perfection, you need a roasting pan that is up to the job.
Nowadays, there are lots to choose from, and making up your mind can be tricky – so for anyone who is in the market for a new one, here are our top picks for best roasting pan to help you make the right decision.
1. Circulon 17 Inch x 13 Inch Nonstick Roasting Pan
The Circulon non-stick roasting pan measures 17” x 13”, making it large enough for a turkey of up to around 20lb. It features a U-shaped design, which is great for keeping meat from touching the bottom, and it is made of heavy-gauge steel for superior heat distribution.
Since it is non-stick, it has a temperature limit of 450°F, but this is plenty for most roasting applications you will need it for. It is also free of PFOA, lead and cadmium, giving you the peace of mind that no harmful chemicals will be getting into your food.
On the downside, it is a little awkward to wash. It is dishwasher safe, but hand washing is recommended, and even then, it is a little tricky. Also, it is intended to be a budget-friendly pan, and the quality is as not as high as some more expensive options.
In sum, if you want a solid pan for roasting even relatively large birds or other meat – and you don’t want to spend a fortune – this is a roasting pan that should be on your list of possibilities.
- Heavy-gauge steel construction – for better heat distribution
- Very affordable price – a good budget option
- Oven safe to 450°F – plenty for most roasting jobs
- Free of PFOA, lead and cadmium – a good healthy option
- U-shaped tray – keeps meat from touching the bottom
- Cleaning awkward – dishwasher safe but hand washing recommended
- Not high quality – this is not supposed to be a high-end pan
2. Calphalon 16″ x 13″ Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Rack
This is a beautiful, shiny stainless-steel roasting pan and rack from Calphalon. It boasts heavy-duty construction, featuring a heavy-gauge aluminum core surrounded by stainless steel, making this a roaster that is built to last many years.
It is designed to have superior conductivity, meaning the heat is dispersed evenly, giving you the greatest possible control over the cooking process. It includes useful handles, and it can also be placed on the stove for making gravy.
The main negatives concern the rack. First, if you are not roasting a large bird, the rack might be too big, and the rungs are spaced too far apart. Second, it can move if you’re not careful, and you need to learn how to manipulate it so the rack stays still.
However, despite these minor issues, we still think this is a top product, so for anyone looking for a high-quality and reliable roasting pan, this is one that should be of interest.
- Large roasting rack – big enough for a 25lb turkey
- Durable construction – heavy-gauge aluminum core surrounded by stainless steel
- Superior conductivity – for more even heating and better control
- Useful handles – make it easy to lift, even when full
- Dishwasher friendly – makes it convenient to clean
- Rack is too large for smaller birds – rungs spaced too far apart
- Rack can move about a bit – you need to be careful not to let it shift
3. Calphalon 16 Inch Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack
This is another roasting pan and rack from Calphalon, but this time it’s a non-stick hard-anodized aluminum version. This means it has a temperature limit of 450°F, but this is plenty for most uses.
We like the stainless-steel handles that make it easy to carry or move, and the elevated rack allows juices to drain away easily. It’s also easy to clean after use, and you shouldn’t have any issues with food being hard to remove.
That said, one downside is that it isn’t dishwasher safe, so you’ll have to wash it by hand each time you use it. Also, it is a little small for the largest turkeys, so if you want to cook a big bird, you might find it a little awkward.
All in all, this is another solid product from a reputable brand. If you are looking for a roasting pan you can trust and you prefer a non-stick version, this could be an obvious choice.
- Medium-gauge hard-anodized aluminum – tough non-stick material
- Oven safe up to 450°F – enough for almost all uses
- Stainless-steel handles – makes it easy and convenient to transport
- Elevated rack – allows fat to drain away
- Easy to clean – can clean food off it effortless after use
- Hand wash only – not suitable for dishwashers
- Slightly small for bigger birds – makes it a little difficult to maneuver
4. Cuisinart 16 Inch Stainless Roaster with Rack
At 16”, this roaster from Cuisinart is big enough for all but the largest turkeys or other similar large roasting jobs. It is a robust pan with stainless triple-ply construction and a stainless exterior. It also features strong riveted handles for ease of carrying, even when full.
One advantage is the heat surround technology that ensures whatever you are roasting is cooked thoroughly. We also appreciate the drip-free pouring system that allows you to drain off any juices without splashing or making a mess.
One minor negative is that the handles stick out a bit, which can make it a little awkward to fit in the oven, especially if you want to put anything else in there at the same time. Also, the rack is on the light side and can move around in the pan.
However, despite these minor drawbacks, this is an excellent product from a reputable brand – and at such a low price point, you can hardly go wrong.
- Stainless triple-ply construction – tough and durable
- Heat surround technology – helps distribute heat evenly
- Riveted handles – easy to move and carry
- Drip-free pouring – helps avoid splashes and mess
- Dishwasher friendly – easy to clean
- Handles stick out a little – can be awkward to fit in the oven
- Rack is on the light side – can move around in the pan
5. Cooks Standard 16″ X 13″ Stainless Steel Roasting with Rack
This pan measures 16” x 13” and has an oven temperature limit of 500°F, making it suitable for almost any roasting job. It is large enough to hold even a big turkey, and it features strong and sturdy handles for when you need to lift it.
We like the way it offers even conductivity, cooking your food uniformly and given an even browning. It is also compatible with many kinds of stovetops, and it is dishwasher safe too, giving you an extra level of convenience when the time comes to clean up.
Having said that, it is not compatible with induction stovetops, so if you have one of those, this is not the best pick. Also, the rack can move about slightly – although only a little, so this shouldn’t be a deal-breaker.
Overall, a solid pick if you are looking for a mid-priced pan that can hold a large bird and that gives you good, even cooking. If that’s the kind of thing you’re looking for, this is an option that should be on your list of possibilities.
- Even conductivity – helps ensure food is cooked uniformly
- Oven safe to 500°F – plenty of temperature for most roasting jobs
- Dishwasher safe – for extra convenience
- Suitable for many types of stovetops – gas, electric, glass, ceramic
- Sturdy handles – for ease of movement
- Rack slides a little – but not a huge issue
- Not induction stovetop compatible – but can be used with most others
6. Rachael Ray 16″ x 12″ Nonstick Roasting Pan with Rack
If you are looking for a high-quality non-stick roasting pan, this one could be worth a look. It measures 16” x 12” and features a useful dual-height rack that gives you more flexibility over how you cook while keeping the meat and juices separate.
It has a PFOA-free non-stick coating, and it is also oven safe up to 500°F, allowing you to use it for just about any kind of roasting jobs you need it for. It’s also super-easy to wash and will usually wipe clean with just a sponge, warm water and light detergent.
That said, it isn’t dishwasher safe, so if you don’t want to wash it by hand, it might not be a good pick. Also, the rack doesn’t have separate handles, but this is only a minor complaint.
In sum, a top-quality roaster if you prefer to go non-stick. If that’s what you’re thinking of buying, this is an option that should be on your radar.
- Dual-height rack – gives you more flexibility over how you cook
- Hard-anodized non-stick pan – PFOA-free
- Oven safe to 500°F – plenty for almost any roasting jobs
- Easy to wash – wipes clean with a sponge and detergent
- Sturdy stainless-steel handles – easy to lift and transport
- Hand wash only – not dishwasher safe
- No handles on the rack – although only a minor issue
7. Farberware 11″ x 15″ Nonstick Steel Roasting with Flat Rack
As far as budget-friendly pans go, this could be a great option. It features a non-stick coating and is oven safe up to 450°F, making it ideal for a range of cooking applications. It includes a chrome rack that keeps the meat above the tray below, allowing you to collect the juices.
It heats evenly, ensuring your food is cooked uniformly throughout. After use, it is also very easy to clean, so you won’t need to spend lots of time scrubbing off stubborn stains and burnt-on food.
On the downside, we find the handles can be a little awkward to grab hold of when it’s full. Also, it might be on the small side if you want to cook larger turkeys – although if you want a smaller pan, this one could be perfect.
To summarize, a great option for anyone who wants a small to the medium non-stick roasting pan but who doesn’t want to spend a fortune. If that sounds like you, this could just the pan you need.
- Great price – very budget-friendly option
- Heats evenly – ensures your food is cooked throughout
- Easy to clean – no stubborn food stuck to it after use
- Oven safe to 450°F – enough for most applications
- Heavy duty – will resist damage and warping
- Handles a little awkward – they flip up and can be difficult to get hold of
- On the small side – not suited to cooking larger birds
8. Chicago Metallic 13″ X 9″ Professional Non-Stick Roasting Pan
If you are looking for the most affordable roasting pan solution, this one could be a no-brainer. It is among the least expensive available, but it still does its job extremely well. It is non-stick, making washing up easy, and it is also dishwasher safe for extra convenience.
We like the way it has such good heat conduction for an affordable pan. This will allow you to roast your food thoroughly and evenly. It is also safe for use in temperatures of up to 450°F, making it suitable for most home cooking purposes.
Our main worry is that the non-stick coat seems a little delicate and might not last so long. Also, this is not a high-quality product – but at this price point, it isn’t supposed to be, and if you get a couple of years’ use, it’s still money well spent.
This could be a great option if you are looking for a pan for occasional use that costs as little as possible. If that’s the kind of product you’re looking for, this pan could be a winner.
- Extremely affordable option – among the least expensive pans around
- Good heat conduction – ensures more even roasting
- Non-stick – for easy clean-up after use
- Dishwasher safe – no need to clean it manually
- Oven safe up to 450°F – enough for roasting most types of meat
- Non-stick coat delicate – not sure how many years it will last
- Not high-end quality – not supposed to be a top-quality pan
9. Granite Ware 18″ Large Covered Oval Roasting Pan
This roasting pan is constructed with a steel core for even heat distribution and strength along with a porcelain exterior. Since porcelain is inert, it doesn’t affect the flavor of your food, and it is also free of substances like PFOA and PTFE, making it a healthier choice for your family.
We like the size – it can hold a 15lb bird with the lid closed or a larger one with the lid off. It is also dishwasher friendly, so you don’t need to worry about cleaning by hand after use. Finally, it’s made in the USA, something that may be important to some people.
On the downside, you might find the lid is not a perfect fit – but this is more a minor irritation than a major problem. Also, you can’t use it on a glass stovetop, although it will be fine on most other types.
A great pick for anyone who wants a roaster that is reasonably priced, free of harmful chemicals and made in the USA. If that sounds like the kind of product you’re looking for, this could be a smart choice.
- Porcelain core – inert and doesn’t affect the flavor of food
- No harmful chemicals – free of PFOA and PTFE
- Generous size – large enough for 15lb bird with a lid on or 18lb with lid off
- Good heat distribution – allows you to cook your food evenly
- Made in USA – a trusted all-American company
- Lid doesn’t fit tight – not quite a perfect fit
- Not suitable for glass stovetops – but most other types are fine
10. Viking Culinary 16″ x 13″ Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack
If you are looking for a reliable and solid roaster that will last many years, this option from Viking Culinary could be just what you need. It is extremely sturdy, is suitable for any cooktop and has a temperature limit of 600°F, so you can use it for just about anything.
Furthermore, it’s also refrigerator safe, so you can place it directly in the refrigerator after use – after it’s cooled, of course. We like the comfortable handles, and we also appreciate the convenient handles on the rack, making it easy to lift out even when full.
There’s little we can find to complain about here. Perhaps we could say that, unlike the pan itself, the rack is not dishwasher safe and needs to be cleaned manually. However, this is hardly a big issue.
Other than that, the only problem is the price because it’s not cheap. However, you expect to pay more for top-quality products, and if that’s what you want, this could be an obvious pan to go for.
- Large and heavy duty – suitable for almost any type of roasting
- Suitable for any cooktop surfaces – and safe up to 600°F
- V-shaped non-stick rack – with handles for extra convenience
- Comfortable side handles – makes it easier to lift and carry
- Refrigerator safe – can place it directly in the refrigerator after cooking
- Expensive option – but good value for a top-end pan
- Rack not dishwasher safe – only a minor issue
What to Look for When Buying a Roasting Pan?
If you’re looking for the best roasting pan, you’ll probably be wondering about the features you should pay attention when choosing. Let’s have a look at some of the most important ones now.
Non-stick or not?
One of the first things you need to think about is whether you want to go non-stick. The advantages of non-stick are that food doesn’t become attached to it while you’re cooking, and it’s easier to clean when you’ve finished.
However, the non-stick surface can wear off with time, reducing its performance levels, and some people might also be worried about non-stick materials containing harmful chemicals. Non-stick also tends to have a lower temperature limit.
If you choose something that isn’t non-stick, it will probably last longer, you won’t have to worry about chemicals and it will probably have a higher temperature limit – but you will also find that food gets stuck to it and it can be harder to clean.
You should pay attention to how sturdy a pan is. You will need to pay more money for a more rugged pan, but at the same time, if you’re only going to use it once or twice a year, this might not be important.
Consider how much you are willing to pay compared to how often you plan to use it – and remember that paying less for a pan that is going to see lots of use could well end up being a false economy.
Good-quality pans ensure that your food is cooked uniformly because the heat is distributed more evenly. This is important for more precise cooking – otherwise, you will find some parts are overcooked and others are undercooked.
Think about the size of poultry or other meat you need to roast in your pan. If you are looking to roast the largest-sized turkeys, make sure you choose a pan that can accommodate a bird of this size.
The handles are an important element, so make sure that your pan has handles and that they are comfortable and easy to grab hold of. It’s one thing to pick up an empty pan – but it’s another entirely to have to carry a hot pan with a large roast turkey in it.
Does it come with a rack? How high is the rack? Does the rack have separate handles? These are all important questions, so think about what you need your pan for and choose one with a rack that will do what you need it for.
Lots of great options to choose from
As you can see, there are plenty of great options to choose from, ranging from top-end products to more budget-friendly versions. If you are searching for the best roasting pan but are having trouble deciding, any of the picks in our review would be a great place to start.