10 Best Pizza Pans 2020 – Steel Pizza Pan With Holes Reviews

Almost everyone loves pizza, but if you want it to be cooked to perfection with dripping melted cheese and a crispy crust – but no burnt bits – you need the right equipment to do it.

There are loads of pans to pick from, and choosing the right one can be a challenge – so here are our top picks for the best pizza pan to help you make the right decision.

Quick Summary: Best Pizza Pan 2020

Product

Weight

Dimensions

Our Rating

best pizza pan Cuisinart

Cuisinart 14" Chef's Classic Nonstick Pizza Pan

1.14 pounds

15 x 14.4 x 1 inches

best pizza pan Wilton

Wilton 14" Non-Stick Pizza Pan

1.15 pounds

14.1 x 0.36 x 14.1 inches

best pizza pan Lodge

Lodge 14" Cast Iron Pizza Pan With Loop Handles

9.53 pounds

18.43 x 14.75 x 1.25 inches

best pizza pan Winco

Winco 16" Seamless Aluminum Pizza Pan

5.9 ounces

16 x 16 x 0.1 inches

best pizza pan New Star Foodservice

New Star Foodservice 10" Aluminum Pizza Pan

3.2 ounces

10 x 10 x 1 inches

best pizza pan Calphalon

Calphalon 7" 4 Pack Mini Pizza Pan With Holes

1 pounds

7 x 7 x 1 inches

best pizza pan Calphalon

Calphalon 16" Pizza Pan With Holes

1.2 pounds

16 x 16 x 0.75 inches

best pizza pan AirBake

AirBake 12.75" Nonstick Pizza Pan With Holes

12 ounces

13.6 x 1.4 x 13.7 inches

best pizza pan T-fal

T-fal 16" Signature Nonstick Pizza Pan

1.55 pounds

16.3 x 16.3 x 0.6 inches

best pizza pan G&S Metal

G&S Metal Products 16" Non-Stick Pizza Pan

1.19 pounds

16 x 0.25 x 16 inches

The Best Pizza Pan Reviews 2020

1. Cuisinart 14 Inch Nonstick Pizza Pan With Holes

OUR TOP PICK
Pizza Pan With Holes Cuisinart

  • Heavy-gauge aluminumized steel – tough construction and built to last
  • Thick-rolled edges – designed to minimize warping
  • Dishwasher safe – and easy to clean even manually
  • Perforated bottom – for even and thorough cooking
  • Excellent value – great bang for your buck

This pizza pan from Cuisinart measures 14” and features a perforated base that helps give you a crispier and more thoroughly cooked pizza. It also boasts thick-rolled edges that minimize warping, and its heavy-gauge aluminumized steel construction ensures it will last a long time.

After you finish using it, it’s easy to clean up – and it’s also dishwasher safe, so you won’t need to worry about cleaning it manually. It also sells at a very reasonable price point, meaning you get great bang for your buck.

There’s not much we don’t like about this pan, but we could complain that the non-stick surface is not perfect – although it works well if you give it a light coat of oil first. The non-stick coating is also a little delicate, so you need to treat it gently to keep it intact.

However, these minor issues aside, we think this is an excellent product that represents great value for money and does its job well. If those are the kind of qualities you’re looking for in a pizza pan, this one could be a smart pick.

Pros

  • Heavy-gauge aluminumized steel – tough construction and built to last
  • Thick-rolled edges – designed to minimize warping
  • Dishwasher safe – and easy to clean even manually
  • Perforated bottom – for even and thorough cooking
  • Excellent value – great bang for your buck

Cons

  • Non-stick not perfect – but works well with a light coating of oil
  • Delicate surface – you need to treat it gently

Check Latest Price on Amazon

 

2. Wilton 14 Inch Non-Stick  Steel Pizza Pan

steel pizza pan Wilton

  • Good non-stick surface – pizza slides right off after cooking
  • Dishwasher safe – although better to clean with warm soapy water
  • Exceptional value – very low price
  • 5-year warranty – for extra peace of mind
  • Durable pan – built to last

For people who prefer no-frills kitchen tools, this is a pizza pan that should be of interest. It measures 14” and is made of steel with an effective non-stick coating that ensures your pizza slides off the pan when it’s ready. It also has a five-year warranty for extra peace of mind.

We like the fact that this pan is dishwasher safe – although it is better to wash it by hand with warm soapy water. However, since it is so easy to clean, this only takes a few moments, making this another advantage of this pan. If you look after it, it will last a long time too.

That said, the non-stick surface is a little delicate, so you should avoid using metal utensils with this pan – and never cut the pizza on the pan. Also, it can become a little less rigid when it’s hot, so you need to be careful handling it when you remove it from the oven.

All in all, a great option for anyone who wants a no-nonsense budget-friendly pizza pan they can rely on. It’s easy to use, simple to clean and gets the job done. Another option worth considering.

Pros

  • Good non-stick surface – pizza slides right off after cooking
  • Dishwasher safe – although better to clean with warm soapy water
  • Exceptional value – very low price
  • 5-year warranty – for extra peace of mind
  • Durable pan – built to last

Cons

  • Can become less rigid when hot – need to be careful handling it
  • Surface can scratch – avoid touching it with metal utensils

Check Latest Price on Amazon

 

3. Calphalon 16 Inch Pizza Pan With Holes

Pizza Pan With Holes Calphalon

  • Even heat distribution – no hot spots that can burn pizzas
  • Large size – suitable for families
  • Perforated base – allows air to circulate, giving a crispier finish
  • Dishwasher friendly – saves time during clean-up
  • Lifetime warranty – covers you if anything goes wrong

This is a 16” pizza pan from Calphalon, so if you’re looking for something that can hold larger-sized pizzas, this could be an ideal pick. It is made from heavy-gauge steel and features perforations in the base to allow air to circulate, giving you a delicious crispy crust.

We like the way it distributes the heat evenly, ensuring there are no hot spots that will burn parts of your pizza.

Since it’s dishwasher friendly, you can save time when you need to clean up after using it – although it’s easy to wash manually too.

However, we find that the perforations are a little small and perhaps slightly bigger ones would have been a better choice. Also, it can start to warp at higher temperatures, but as long as you don’t try to incinerate your pizzas, it should be fine.

In sum, an ideal pick for anyone who needs a pan for bigger pizzas and who wants something that can produce evenly cooked pizzas with a crispy crust. If that sounds like you, this pan could be well worth checking out.

Pros

  • Even heat distribution – no hot spots that can burn pizzas
  • Large size – suitable for families
  • Perforated base – allows air to circulate, giving a crispier finish
  • Dishwasher friendly – saves time during clean-up
  • Lifetime warranty – covers you if anything goes wrong

Cons

  • Small perforations – slightly larger would be better
  • Can warp at higher temperatures – but fine if you don’t heat it excessively

Check Latest Price on Amazon

 

4. Calphalon 7 Inch 4 Pack Mini Pizza Pan With Holes

steel pizza pan Calphalon

  • Good non-stick performance – pizzas slide right off
  • Perforated for airflow – for a crispier base
  • Dishwasher safe – for easier clean-up
  • Made of heavy-gauge steel – will last a long time
  • Lifetime warranty – so you know you’re covered if there’s a problem

If you like the sound of the large Calphalon pizza pan above but you prefer to make smaller individual pizzas, this set of four mini pizza pans could be the ideal alternative. They measure 7” each and are made of heavy-gauge steel, ensuring they will last a long time.

We like how effective the non-stick coating is – you will find your pizzas just slide off right after cooking. They also have perforated bases, which means they will give you pizzas with delicious crispy bases.

Having said that, we find that the holes are a little small – like with the larger version we looked at above. Perhaps bigger holes would have been better for even crispier pizzas.

Also, the non-stick surface eventually wears off, although this is normal with all non-stick cookware – but you can prolong their life by washing them carefully by hand rather than using the dishwasher.

Other than that, there’s a lot to like about these pans. They’re cute pans that do the job they were designed for perfectly. Another product that’s worth a look.

Pros

  • Good non-stick performance – pizzas slide right off
  • Perforated for airflow – for a crispier base
  • Dishwasher safe – for easier clean-up
  • Made of heavy-gauge steel – will last a long time
  • Lifetime warranty – so you know you’re covered if there’s a problem

Cons

  • Non-stick surface wears off – although normal in all non-stick pans
  • Bigger holes would have been better – but they still work well

Check Latest Price on Amazon

 

5. Winco 16 Inch Seamless Aluminum Pizza Pan

best pizza pan Winco

  • Helps cook a pizza thoroughly and evenly – good for a crispy base
  • Inexpensive option – very affordable screen
  • Aluminum construction – will last a long time
  • Large size – suitable for a range of pizza sizes
  • Easy to use – and gives consistently great results

For anyone who needs an easy way to cook pizza that will give consistently great results, this pizza screen from Winco could be a winner. It is made of aluminum, and it allows the heat to reach the base of the pizza, giving you a good crispy crust and bottom.

We like the size of this screen – at 16”, it’s big enough for most pizzas. Thanks to its durable construction, it should last a long time – and since it is so affordable, it’s also hardly a problem to replace it when the time comes.

Note that this is a pizza “screen” rather than a “pan” – although this is not a negative point. It’s a highly effective method of cooking pizzas, but perhaps it isn’t a versatile as a true “pan”. Also, sometimes food can get stuck in the grille, making it a little hard to clean.

This is the ideal solution for someone who wants something to place their pizzas on when they go in the oven – although if you want a proper pan that can also be used for other cooking applications, this might not be the best pick.

Pros

  • Helps cook a pizza thoroughly and evenly – good for a crispy base
  • Inexpensive option – very affordable screen
  • Aluminum construction – will last a long time
  • Large size – suitable for a range of pizza sizes
  • Easy to use – and gives consistently great results

Cons

  • Not actually a “pan” – but a great way to cook pizza
  • Can be awkward to clean – pieces of food get stuck in the gaps

Check Latest Price on Amazon

 

6. T-fal 16 Inch Signature Nonstick Pizza Pan

best pizza pan T-fal

  • Consistent heating – cooks your pizzas evenly
  • Non-stick surface – easy to clean after use
  • Rolled edges – designed to prevent warping
  • Versatile pan – can be put to other uses
  • Great value – very reasonable price for a solid pizza pan

While some people like a perforated pan that allows hot air to reach the base of the pizza, others might prefer a solid base that stops juices and crumbs from dripping down or falling into your oven.

If you prefer the latter, this T-fal pizza pan could be for you. It is well built, features an effective non-stick coating and can heat pizzas consistently and evenly. It’s a versatile pan since it can be used for other cooking tasks, and it also sells at a very reasonable price point.

Like most other non-stick cookware, you have to treat it carefully to make it last – and the coating will eventually wear off however you treat it. Also, note that this is a large pan, so check that it will fit in your oven before buying it.

For anyone looking for a large, versatile pan that can be used for cooking pizzas and more, this could be a great pick – and for a well-known brand at this kind of price, you can hardly go wrong.

Pros

  • Consistent heating – cooks your pizzas evenly
  • Non-stick surface – easy to clean after use
  • Rolled edges – designed to prevent warping
  • Versatile pan – can be put to other uses
  • Great value – very reasonable price for a solid pizza pan

Cons

  • Non-stick coating delicate – like many other non-stick pans
  • Large size – check that it will fit in your oven!

Check Latest Price on Amazon

 

7. G&S Metal Products 16 Inch NonStick Pizza Pan

best pizza pan G&S Metal Products

  • Teflon non-stick coating – easy to wash and pizza slides right off
  • Raised edges – makes it easy and comfortable to pick up
  • Looks good – a highly attractive pizza pan
  • Steel construction – built to last
  • Affordable option – represents great value for money

Here is another non-nonsense non-stick pizza pan, this time with a Teflon coating that allows the pizza to slide off when it’s done and greatly facilitates washing it. We also like the slightly raised edges that make it easy to pick up and comfortable to hold.

The steel construction is another plus since this is a pizza pan that should last some time. It also looks great, which, while not the most important feature, is something that will appeal to many people. The price tag is reasonable, too, making this a real bargain.

We might complain that the material is a little thin – this can mean it warps a little when it’s hot, but this is hardly a deal-breaker. Also, the sticker it comes with is quite annoying to take off. We wonder why companies insist on using stickers like this on cookware.

However, despite these minor gripes, this is an affordable pan that can produce great results, and if you take care of it, it should last for a good amount of time. If you need a large non-stick pizza pan, this is another one that should be on your list of possibilities.

Pros

  • Teflon non-stick coating – easy to wash and pizza slides right off
  • Raised edges – makes it easy and comfortable to pick up
  • Looks good – a highly attractive pizza pan
  • Steel construction – built to last
  • Affordable option – represents great value for money

Cons

  • Slightly thin material – can warp a little when hot
  • Annoying sticker on the pan – difficult to get off before you use it

Check Latest Price on Amazon

 

8. Lodge 14 Inch Cast Iron Pizza Pan With Loop Handles

best pizza pan Lodge

  • Extremely durable – cast iron is practically indestructible
  • Large handles – makes it easy to get hold of
  • Versatile pan – can be used for pizzas but also many other dishes
  • Suitable for most cooking applications – oven, stove, induction, barbecue etc.
  • Excellent heat retention and distribution – for perfectly even cooking

This pizza pan from Lodge is a cast-iron model that can be used for a range of dishes and with most cooking styles. You can put it in the oven, but you can also place it on the stove – including induction stoves – on the barbecue, on the campfire or just about anything else.

It offers exceptional heat retention and distribution, meaning you won’t have any problems with hot spots that can burn your pizza. Another big plus is the large handles – these make it easy to pick up and comfortable to carry.

The only real problems with this pan come from the fact it is made of cast iron rather than any issues with the pan itself.

It is quite heavy, as you would expect, so if you don’t have the strength to lift it, you might prefer a pan made of a different material. Also, there is a certain learning curve when cooking on cast iron, so if you’re not used to it, don’t expect it to be perfect first time.

Overall, this is a wonderful piece of cookware if you are looking for a cast-iron pizza pan. It is a bit pricier than some of the other pans in our review, but it should last practically forever, making it a great investment if you want a pan you will be using for years to come.

Pros

  • Extremely durable – cast iron is practically indestructible
  • Large handles – makes it easy to get hold of
  • Versatile pan – can be used for pizzas but also many other dishes
  • Suitable for most cooking applications – oven, stove, induction, barbecue etc.
  • Excellent heat retention and distribution – for perfectly even cooking

Cons

  • Heavy pan – as you would expect with cast iron
  • Learning curve when cooking with cast iron – but great when you master it

Check Latest Price on Amazon

 

9. AirBake 12.75 Inch Nonstick Pizza Pan With Holes

Pizza Pan With Holes AirBake

  • Easy to clean – food wipes off with no problem
  • Good non-stick surface – pizzas slide off after cooking
  • Perforated base – for crispy pizza crust and bottom
  • Lightweight – easy to lift and carry
  • Reasonable price – affordable non-stick option

If you were interested in the T-fal pan we looked at above but think you might prefer a perforated version, this one could be the ideal alternative. It features an effective non-stick surface that makes it easy to clean and allows cooked pizzas to slide right off.

The perforated surface allows hot air to reach the base of the pizza, giving you a crispier bottom and edges. It’s also very light, so it’s no problem to pick up and carry, even with a whole pizza on it.

There’s not much we can find wrong with this pan. We could say that it can warp slightly when hot, although this doesn’t affect how it cooks the pizza.

Also, the non-stick surface will eventually wear off – although this is normal with any non-stick cookware, and if you are gentle with it and wash it by hand, it can still last a good amount of time.

This is a solid pizza pan that sells at a very affordable price and that produces excellent results. Another option that should be of interest.

Pros

  • Easy to clean – food wipes off with no problem
  • Good non-stick surface – pizzas slide off after cooking
  • Perforated base – for crispy pizza crust and bottom
  • Lightweight – easy to lift and carry
  • Reasonable price – affordable non-stick option

Cons

  • Can warp when hot – although doesn’t affect performance
  • Non-stick surface wears off – treat it gently to prolong its life

Check Latest Price on Amazon

 

10. New Star Foodservice 10 Inch Aluminum Pizza Pan

best pizza pan New Star Foodservice

  • Super-affordable pan – one of the least expensive we’ve seen
  • Great shape – curved sides perfect for toppings right up to the edge
  • Aluminum construction – no non-stick surface that can wear off
  • Suitable for slicing in the pan – for extra convenience
  • Range of sizes – choose the right one for your needs

For anyone looking for a practical and convenient pizza pan at the bottom of the price range, this could be the option you need. It is about as inexpensive as you could hope, but it still does a great job of cooking pizza.

One thing we like is the shape of the sides – with this pan you can pile up toppings right to the edge. Also, you can slice pizza directly in the pan, making it even more convenient – although you’re probably best avoiding metal slicers if you want it to stay in perfect condition.

One drawback is that it isn’t dishwasher safe, so you’ll have to wash it by hand. Also, the material it is made from is slightly thin – but at this price point, you can hardly complain about this.

Overall, a great option if you want a pizza pan that costs as little as possible. It’s available in several sizes, so you can find the perfect one for your needs, making this a top option if you don’t want to spend more than you have to.

Pros

  • Super-affordable pan – one of the least expensive we’ve seen
  • Great shape – curved sides perfect for toppings right up to the edge
  • Aluminum construction – no non-stick surface that can wear off
  • Suitable for slicing in the pan – for extra convenience
  • Range of sizes – choose the right one for your needs

Cons

  • Not dishwasher safe – but easy to wash by hand
  • Slightly thin material – but still great for the price

Check Latest Price on Amazon

 

What to Look for When Buying a Pizza Pan?

Pizza Pan With Holes

If you’re in the market for a new pizza pan, you’ll probably be wondering about the kind of factors you should consider when making up your mind – so let’s look at some of the most important ones now.

Non-stick

best pizza pans

Most pizza pans nowadays are non-stick. This means the metal has a special coating that prevents food from sticking to the pan, allowing the pizza to slide off and greatly facilitating the clean-up afterward.

However, not all non-stick pans perform to the same level, so if you decide to go non-stick, make sure the coating does its job well.

Non-stick coatings also wear off with time, so you should make sure the one you choose will give you at least a good few years of use before needing to be replaced.

On the other hand, due to the limited lifespan of non-stick cookware as well as concerns about the potential impact it may have on your health, some people prefer to avoid non-stick. In this case, you may prefer to opt for a different material such as cast iron or stainless steel.

Perforated

perforated pizza pan

One of the big decisions you will need to make is whether to go for a pan with a perforated bottom.

Perforated bottoms allow hot air to reach the base of your pizza, giving you a crispier base and a pizza that is more thoroughly cooked.

However, pans with perforated bottoms can let juices and crumbs fall into your oven, and they are also less versatile.

This means you need to weigh up the pros and cons of each and then make your decision.

Heat distribution

A pizza pan should distribute heat evenly. If not, it will have hot spots, and this will mean your pizza ends up getting burned in some places while it remains undercooked in others.

Size

Make sure you choose a pizza pan that is the correct size for your needs. If you are buying a large one, it might be worth measuring your oven – because it won’t be much use if it arrives and you find it won’t go in.

Warranty

Look for pizza pans that have a long warranty. This will give you the peace of mind that you’re covered if anything goes wrong.

YouTube video

 

Lots of great options to choose from

As you can see, there are many styles of the pan to suit just about any budget. If you have decided you need a new one but are still having trouble choosing the best pizza pan for you, any of the picks in our review would be a great place to start your search.

Leave a Comment