The Pan Handler is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

10 Best Muffin Pans Reviews

Baking muffins is a great pleasure that many of us enjoy and take pride in, but to achieve the best results, you need the right equipment – and that means a reliable muffin pan.

There are so many pans on the market nowadays, and sometimes it can be a little tough deciding which one to go for. If you’re facing this dilemma, here are our top picks for best muffin pan to help you make the right choice.

1. Wilton 6 Cup NonStick Jumbo Muffin Pan – 2 Pack

This is a pair of high-quality but reasonably priced muffin pans for making jumbo-sized muffins. They feature a non-stick coating, and the heavy-gauge material they are made from is resistant to warping. They hold six muffins each and produce delicious muffins with light crusts.

We like the way they come with a five-year warranty – this gives you the peace of mind that you’re covered if anything should go wrong. They are also dishwasher friendly, but washing them by hand will help extend their lifespan.

On the downside, the non-stick coating isn’t 100% effective, and you will achieve better results if you use a bit of butter. Also, sometimes they can be a little difficult to clean, and you might have to work hard to get all the bits of muffin to come off.

However, despite these minor complaints, these are still wonderful muffin pans to cook with, so if you want to make jumbo-sized muffins in high-quality but reasonably priced pans, this could be a great pick.


  • Heavy-gauge material – resistant to warping
  • Very reasonable price – affordable for good quality pans
  • Dishwasher friendly – but better to wash by hand
  • Produce good results – tasty muffins with light crusts
  • 5-year warranty – for extra peace of mind


  • Non-stick not perfect – better results with a little butter
  • Can be difficult to clean – need to work to get all the food off


2. Nordic Ware 12 Cup Natural Aluminum Commercial Muffin Pan

If you are looking for a high-quality, no-nonsense pan to cook your muffins in, this could be just the product you need. It is made of aluminum, which is naturally non-stick as well as being resistant to rust. It is easy to clean and will last practically forever.

The material also conducts heat efficiently and evenly, giving you great results every time. Your muffins will rise evenly with a crispy crust but a moist interior. Finally, this pan is made in the USA, something that can be important to many people nowadays.

There’s not much to dislike about this pan. We might complain that you can’t wash it in the dishwasher – although it’s easy to clean by hand, so this isn’t a big problem. Also, the edge is slightly narrow, which makes picking it up a little awkward – but this is hardly a big deal.

All in all, this is a solid and reliable muffin pan that you will be using for many years to come. It is reasonably priced, and if you know how to use it, will always produce delicious muffins. If those sound like the qualities you value, this is a pan that could be worth checking out.


  • Natural aluminum construction – rust-resistant and naturally non-stick
  • Even temperature conductivity – for uniform rising of muffins
  • Easy to clean – muffins won’t stick to the pan
  • Heavy-duty pan – built to last forever
  • Made in the USA – all-American product


  • Not dishwasher friendly – have to wash by hand
  • Narrow around the edge – makes it slightly more difficult to get hold of


3. Silicone Cupcake Pan – Mini 24 Cups and Regular 12 Cups

As an alternative to metal muffin pans, you can try these cute silicone trays instead. They are certified as 100% food-grade silicone, which you can prove with the “pinch test”. The pack contains one tray for 24 muffins, one for 12 and 12 colored muffin cups as a bonus.

One of the best things about silicone is that it is naturally non-stick and easy to clean. Muffins just pop out too because the material is flexible, meaning you won’t have to worry about muffins getting stuck to the tray as they can with metal.

There aren’t many downsides with these pans. Silicone trays are floppy, so you need to remember to place them on a baking tray before you fill them up. There is also a bit of learning curve if you’re used to metal, but it’s no problem when you’ve mastered it.

In sum, a great alternative to metal. They’re easy to use, produce excellent results, are quick and easy to clean and sell for a very reasonable price – so what’s not to like? Another highly recommended option.


  • Non-stick – easy to clean after use
  • Muffins pop out – because silicone is flexible
  • 100% food-grade silicone – pass the “pinch test”
  • Can withstand a wide range of temperatures – from -104°F to 446°F
  • Come with 12 colorful muffin cups – extras bonus


  • Silicone pans floppy – need to put them on a baking tray before filling
  • Learning curve if used to metal – but easy to use when you know how


4. Rachael Ray 12 Cup Nonstick Muffin Tin

This is a 12-muffin pan from Rachel Ray that incorporates several features that we like a lot. It is made of heavy-gauge steel, making it tough and resistant to warping. It also boasts a lasting non-stick coating that allows it to keep its non-stick properties for longer.

Another positive is that this pan can withstand high temperatures – even up to 500°F. This is more than you will need for making muffins, but it means you can use it for cooking other things too, making it a versatile pan. Finally, it includes cute handles that make it easy to hold.

One slight negative is that this tray is a bit more expensive than comparable pans. However, it’s only a couple of bucks so it shouldn’t put you off.

Another point is that muffins tend to cook more underneath than on the sides, but this is a minor issue that is hardly worth mentioning.

We like this pan a lot, and if you are looking for a reliable pan that you are likely to be baking muffins in for many years to come, Rachel Ray’s pan could be the right one for you.


  • Lasting non-stick coating – keeps non-stick properties for longer
  • Heavy-gauge steel construction – tough and warp-resistant
  • Can withstand up to 500°F – makes it a versatile tray suitable for other uses
  • Free of PFDA, lead and cadmium – safe for your health
  • Includes orange grips – helps you pick it up and carry it


  • Slightly pricy option – a little more than other pans
  • Muffins tend to brown more at the bottom – but only slightly


5.  Circulon 12 Cup Nonstick Cupcake Tin

The Circulon 12-cup muffin tin is a simple, no-frills muffin pan that does the job it was designed for extremely well and with no fuss at all. It resists temperatures of up to 450°F and boasts a premium non-stick coating that performs well and lasts a long time.

We like the large side handles that make it easy to pick up, even when wearing gloves, and we also appreciate the fact that it’s made of heavy-gauge steel, meaning it will last a long time. Finally, it comes at an extremely reasonable price, making it a great bargain too.

There are almost no downsides to speak of. We might complain that it is recommended to wash it by hand – but it is dishwasher safe if you prefer. Also, perhaps it would have been nice to have a choice of colors, but this is a very minor gripe.

This is the kind of pan that will appeal to someone who wants an inexpensive pan with no bells or whistles that will allow you to make delicious muffins with no hassle. If that’s the kind of item you like, this is a pan you will love.


  • Made of heavy-gauge steel – built to last
  • Resists temperatures of up to 450°F – plenty for baking muffins and more
  • Large side handles – make it easy to pick up
  • Premium rim – for performance and longevity
  • Lifetime warranty – in case anything goes wrong


  • Best hand-washed – but can be washed in a dishwasher if you prefer
  • Only available in one color – no other options


6. USA Pan 12 Cpu Cupcake and Muffin Pan

Here we have a high-quality muffin pan from all-American company USA Pan – and as the name suggests, it is made in the USA.

This pan features an Americoat non-stick coating that is free of PTFE, PFOA and BPA, making it safe for your health as well as easy to use and easy to clean.

Since it is made of heavy-gauge aluminumized steel, this is a high-performance pan that will last many years. To prove it, the company also backs it up with a lifetime warranty, so you know you’re covered if anything goes wrong.

The main negative is the price since it costs more than other pans of a similar size. However, you have to pay more for American-made products, and we’re sure many people will be happy to do so. Also, the muffins come out a bit top-heavy, making them hard to stand up.

If you are looking for a high-quality American-made muffin pan that performs exceptionally – and you don’t mind paying a bit extra to get your hands on it, then this option could be a no-brainer.


  • Durable and high-performance material – made of heavy-gauge aluminumized steel
  • Americoat non-stick coating – free of PTFE, PFOA and BPA
  • Lifetime warranty – provides extra peace of mind
  • Easy to clean – food doesn’t stick to the pan
  • Made in the USA – an all-American company


  • More expensive option – but you have to pay more for USA-made
  • Muffins come out top-heavy – hard to make them stand up


7. Cuisinart 6 Cup Chef’s Classic Nonstick Muffin Pan

If you prefer to buy products that are backed up by a well-known brand, Cuisinart is a name you can trust. This pan is made of heavy-gauge steel and features thick rolled edges that are designed to resist warping.

The pan is for making jumbo-sized muffins, and the premium non-stick coating ensures they slide out easily when they are done. We like that it is dishwasher safe, too, making it quick and easy to clean up after use.

You also get the extra peace of mind that comes with a lifetime warranty.

There are very few negatives to mention. We might say that the lip is not big enough to get hold of, so it can be slightly difficult to pick up when wearing gloves. Also, this is just a very basic no-frills option – but for some people, that could be a positive.

If you just want a solid muffin pan from a famous brand with no unnecessary extras, this is an option that fits the bill perfectly, making it an obvious pick if that’s the kind of product you enjoy owning.


  • Heavy-gauge steel construction – ensures even heating
  • Premium non-stick coating – for easy release and easy clean-up
  • Thick rolled edges – designed to resist warping
  • Dishwasher safe – for extra convenience
  • Lifetime guarantee – gives you extra peace of mind


  • No-frills option – but this can be an advantage for some people
  • A little hard to pick up – rim is not big enough


8. Chicago Metallic Professional 12 Cup Non-Stick Muffin Pan

This muffin pan from Chicago Metallic can be used to cook 12 muffins. We like the way it has good heat conduction, meaning your muffins will be heated evenly, and it boasts a tough aluminumized steel construction for extra durability.

If you need a versatile pan that can cook more than just muffins, this could be a good pick – it has a maximum temperature resistance of 450°F, making it suitable for cooking a range of other foods. It also has an effective silicone-based non-stick coating for easy removal.

One thing we like less is the way it has the company name embossed inside one of the cups. This makes it slightly more difficult to turn that muffin out, and it will also be branded with the company logo. Also, each cup has a groove around the top, which can be a pain to clean.

However, if you can live with these minor drawbacks, this is still a top pick. It’s a high-quality pan that should last a long time and that can be used to produce great results time after time. If that’s what you’re looking for, this could be another smart option.


  • Solid construction – heavy aluminumized steel
  • Good heat conduction – results in evenly cooked muffins
  • Versatile tray – can be used to cook many other foods
  • Dishwasher safe – although recommended to wash by hand
  • Maximum temperature of 450°F – ideal for muffins and more


  • Brand name in the bottom of one cup – this muffin tends to stick more
  • Groove around cups – liquid gets in and is harder to clean out


9. Baker’s Advantage 24 Cup Nonstick Mini Muffin Pan

For anyone who needs a pan for making smaller muffins or cupcakes, this could be a great pick. It has a silicone-infused non-stick coating that is free of PFOA and PTFE and is safe to put in the dishwasher or the freezer, making a highly versatile pan.

We like the way the heat is distributed evenly when you use it to cook, ensuring you get consistent results every time. It also sells for a very reasonable price, so it’s great if you like to get good value for money.

We might complain that the non-stick coating is not the most effective we’ve seen – although it still works well. Also, some people might find that the size of the cakes is on the small size – but for others, this could also be an advantage.

Overall, this is a reliable pan that can produce delicious cakes and that won’t cost you a fortune. If that’s all you need, then this one could be perfect.


  • Silicone-infused non-stick coating – free of PFOA and PTFE
  • Safe for both freezer and dishwasher – a versatile pan
  • Even cooking – distributes heat well
  • Very reasonable price – great value for money
  • Ideal for making a range of foods – not just muffins


  • Non-stick non-perfect – although still works most of the time
  • Small muffin size – some people might prefer bigger cakes


10. OvenStuffk 6 Cup Non-Stick Muffin Pan

This is a muffin pan at the lowest end of the price range, so if you want something that will cost as little as possible, this could be the option you’re looking for.

It makes six jumbo-sized muffins and features a PFOA-free non-stick coating that helps them slide out when they’re done.

This pan is made in the USA, which might be important to some people, and it comes with a five-year warranty to give you extra peace of mind if anything goes wrong.

One potential issue could be with the size of this pan – it is very large and might not fit in smaller ovens. Also, it may rust if you don’t wash it and dry it after use – but if you take care of it, it should be fine.

This is the kind of product that will appeal to anyone who doesn’t like to spend any more than is necessary on basic kitchen tools. If you fall into that category, this could be a great pick.


  • Extremely inexpensive – as cheap as you’ll find
  • Non-stick coating – to help muffins slide out
  • PFOA-free – safe for your health
  • 5-year warranty – in case there’s a defect
  • Made in the USA – and all-American product


  • Large pan – may not fit in smaller ovens
  • May rust if not cleaned immediately – but ok if you take care of it


What to Look for When Buying a Muffin Pan?

silicone cupcake pan

If you need a new muffin pan, you will be wondering which features you should be looking at when you choose, so let’s look at the most important ones now.


The material you choose can be an important factor. Metal tins made of stainless steel are a good option. They will last a long time and produce consistent results.

Silicone pans are another choice. They have the advantage of being naturally non-stick, and it is easy to pop your muffins out since silicone trays are flexible. They are also super easy to clean.

However, silicone pans are not rigid, so you need to remember to place them on a baking tray before you fill the cups with the muffin mixture.

Heat distribution

Another important factor is how well the pan distributes heat during the cooking process. If heat is not distributed evenly, parts of the muffins will burn while other parts remain undercooked.


silicone muffin pans reviews

If you choose a metal pan, it may have a non-stick coating. This is good since it helps muffins slide out when they are ready and avoids having them stick to the sides.

If you choose a non-stick pan, you should check how well it performs since not all non-stick coatings are the same.

Also, check what the coating is made of and what it contains. Some people prefer to avoid non-stick coatings that contain PFOA and PTFE since there is some concern that these materials may be dangerous for our health.

Maximum temperature

Check the maximum temperature a tray can withstand. Muffins might not require extreme heat, but if a tray can withstand higher temperatures, it will make it more flexible since you will be able to use it to cook a wider range of foods.

How many muffins?

How many muffins do you want to cook each time? Do you prefer fewer big muffins or a larger number of small ones? Remember to take this into account when you buy.

Dishwasher safe

If you don’t want to wash a muffin pan by hand, you should make sure it is safe to wash it in the dishwasher.

Loads of great options to choose from

As you can see, there are plenty of great options to choose from, in a range of sizes and styles. If you’ve decided it’s time to add a new muffin pan to your kitchen but are having trouble choosing, any of the picks in our review would be a great place to start your search.

4.7/5 - (140 votes)

Leave a Comment